Pine Island, NY Real Estate

Pine Island NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Pine Island NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Pine Island: $484,257 / County Average: $577,648

Average Taxes in Pine Island: $11,440 / County Average: $11,092

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Pine Island: $231 / County Average: $243

Average Walkscore in Pine Island: 19 / County Average: 30

Average Year Built in Pine Island: 1972 / County Average: 1962

Average Days on Website in Pine Island: 74 / County Average: 76

Pine Island NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in Pine Island NY

Pine Island

Areas in Pine Island NY


Most Popular Listing

Popular Pine Island Real Estate
Courtesy of: Griffith Olivero

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Pine Island Real Estate
Courtesy of: Biagini Realty

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Pine Island Real Estate
Courtesy of: Skyler Realty LLC

Listings in Pine Island

55 miles from mid town manhattan. lot of people live in Pine Island and commute to work in nyc. overall its a nice place...

Courtesy of: Sell Your Home Services, LLC

Of warwick and more specifically in the hamlet of Pine Island. this 2,300 sq ft space is the much desired ground floor space with 2 large garage doors f...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

Absolutely beautiful land, level to rolling hills with gorgeous views on this 40 acre parcel...

Courtesy of: Century 21 Geba Realty

Stunning 5 bed, 3 1/2 bath colonial in the Pine Island hamlet of beautiful warwick, ny...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

this property is just steps away from the center of Pine Island and features a large 20 x 40 barn with loft space above. the interior of the home is a blank canvas for you to put your creative ta...

Courtesy of: HomeSmart Homes & Estates

Farm, eaily re-purposed to commercial in the town of warwick...

Courtesy of: Stanley J Nowak

This beautifully designed brand new colonial home features 2,800 square feet of space...

Courtesy of: Biagini Realty

ideal location and the perfect balance you're seeking with close proximity to everyday conveniences of local shops, restaurants and Pine Island park just outside your front door. *warwick school district* and low taxes!...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

Welcome to Pine Island life by the farm. close to oil city wildlife park...

Courtesy of: Skyler Realty LLC

the property with wonderful elevation features spanning vistas and elite privacy, overlooking the pretty ponds of premiere development horizon farms near Pine Island. near the playground, park and fields, courts, golf courses, breweries, wineries, farm markets, antiquing and restaurants, this premier location offers the best ...

Courtesy of: Corcoran Baer & McIntosh

Located in the hamlet of Pine Island. fully approved 5,000 sqft mini-mall, ready to build...

Courtesy of: Raynor Country

invest in orange county's booming economy with this unique landmark property in Pine Island, in the heart of the town of warwick. unbeatable easy access location fea...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

Brand new garage and separate office built in 2020 available for lease...

Courtesy of: Keller Williams Hudson Valley

Calling all hard working, forward thinking opportunists to come, take a look, and visualize the finished product ...

Courtesy of: Joseph Green REALTOR

this property offers privacy as well as proximity to Pine Island and warwick....

Courtesy of: Howard Hanna Rand Realty

138 Pine Island tpke is a lindal cedar post and beam, filled with natural light and set back on 16 acres less than two miles from main street in the village of warwick...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

Beautiful views from this lot, bring your plans and build your dream home...

Courtesy of: Keller Williams Realty

Lity conveniently located on 912 pulaski highway, Pine Island, ny. approximately 7 minutes from route 17 (i-86...

Courtesy of: R J Katz Realty

32.1 acres of lush black dirt. actively farmed....

Courtesy of: Griffith Olivero

close & convenient to restaurants, great pizza, farm stands, shopping, gas station, golf, breweries, pochuck creek and Pine Island town park, appalachian trail and skiing is just outside your door! . only 55 miles to nyc * warwick school district*...

Courtesy of: Green Team New York Realty

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

66 N Broadway
Nyack, NY
Office: 845-284-9460