Highland Lake, NY Real Estate

Highland Lake NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Highland Lake NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Highland Lake: $469,760 / County Average: $445,490

Average Taxes in Highland Lake: $6,312 / County Average: $6,419

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Highland Lake: $273 / County Average: $244

Average Walkscore in Highland Lake: 8 / County Average: 18

Average Year Built in Highland Lake: 1977 / County Average: 1963

Average Days on Website in Highland Lake: 61 / County Average: 87

Highland Lake NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in Highland Lake NY

Highland Lake Lake Devenoge

Areas in Highland Lake NY


Most Popular Listing

Popular Highland Lake Real Estate
Listed by: Payne Team LLC

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Highland Lake Real Estate
Listed by: Payne Team LLC

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Highland Lake Real Estate
Listed by: Diane C. Butler

Listings in Highland Lake

R a well maintained home a stones throw away from Highland Lake? look no further! this hom...

Listed by: K. Fortuna Realty, Inc.

5+ acres of level property on a quiet road just minutes to sand beach where you can enjoy Highland Lake. close to shopping, restaurants, the de...

Listed by: McKean Real Estate, Inc.

Ur own family compound on these 4 lots located in Highland Lake. these ...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

middletown is also the site of the orange county fair each summer and the orange county fair speedway. Highland Lakes state park is the nearest state park. good choices for hiking, biking, and country drives are nearby.shopping in the area includes the galleria at crystal run, a mall just east of middletown, and a long retail strip along route 211 on the east side of town....

Listed by: Keller Williams Realty

come and see this well cared for and quaint 2bed/2bath lake home situated on lake view dr of the gorgeous Highland Lake! this home has been lovingly enjoyed for over the past 2 decades by the same family and ...

Listed by: Century 21 Geba Realty

5 baths, vegetable garden, beautiful grounds, detached 2 car garage and more! located just minutes from Highland Lake's public beach where...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

expansive raised ranch home featuring 6 bedrooms in the Highland Lake estates subdivision! harwood flooring, 2 k...

Listed by: Flag Realty Group

a total of 5.39 acres with 183' of lake frontage on Highland Lake. bring the jet skies and enjoy!...

Listed by: Gibson E McKean Inc

looking for some peace and quiet? we've found it for you here at Highland Lake! located just minutes from the lake and its' ...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

Looking to stretch your legs a little? this ranch home situated back off the road will allow you to do just that...

Listed by: Diane C. Butler

Ke rights to two of sullivan county's best lakes; Highland Lake (motor boat) and lake devenoge (non-motor boat). 2+ acres of leve...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

What's in a lake house? it's the ease and joy of summer, the amazing memories made while enjoying the water, it's the community of families good times are made with, the fishing, the boating, kayaking, and swimming- it's the water calling everyone forward to relax and enjoy its splendor...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

Led on a beautiful brook, and with lake rights to Highland Lake, this 3 bedroom 2 bath home has everything you need. on...

Listed by: Payne Team LLC

Absolutely stunning home located in upscale Highland Lake estates...

Listed by: Howard Hanna Rand Realty

Magnificent lakefront lot on Highland Lake with beautiful lake views and plenty of water activity...

Listed by: Gibson E McKean Inc

5 acre setting? this country contemporary home abuts thousands of acres of protected land via Highland Lakes state park, is within minutes to winding hills park & golf club, only 30 minutes to new paltz and 10 minutes to city winery hudson valley. best of all, 274 tamms road, middletown, ny feels like you are a world away from new york city, yet you are...

Listed by: Corcoran Baer & McIntosh

N a quiet cul-de-sac, backing up to a the lake in Highland Lake estates. enter into a lovely center hall...

Listed by: Howard Hanna Rand Realty

6 beautiful private acres composed of 3 lots and is within 15-30 minutes of some nys's premier horseback riding trail's - minnewaska state park, mohonk preserve, Highland Lakes park, stewart state forest, gardner rail trail, bashakill preserve. only about an hour away from the george washington bridge and would make for the perfect weekend getaway home. the property ...

Listed by: Stonewall Realty Group LLC

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

66 N Broadway
Nyack, NY
Office: 845-284-9460